A newly unearthed 69-million-year-old fossil is shaking up long-standing debates among paleontologists about when modern birds emerged. The discovery of a nearly complete skull from the extinct bird Vegavis iaai suggests that the ancestors of today’s birds coexisted with dinosaurs before the infamous Chicxulub impactor wiped out 75% of Earth’s species 66 million years ago. But the find raises even bigger questions—was Vegavis an early waterfowl, or something entirely different?
The Fossil That Could Settle a Decades-Old Debate
For years, scientists have debated whether modern birds evolved before or after the asteroid impact that ended the Cretaceous Period. The argument hinges on a single question: did any of the birds we see today descend from creatures that shared the world with T. rex?
In 2005, paleontologists first identified Vegavis iaai based on a fossil found in Antarctica, dating back 68 million years. But that specimen was missing most of its skull, making it difficult to confirm whether it truly belonged to modern birds or was simply a close relative.
Now, a new fossil discovered in 2011 and analyzed in a recent study published in Nature appears to provide the missing link. The well-preserved skull reveals key bird-like features, including a long, toothless beak and an enlarged forebrain—traits that match modern birds.
“This new fossil is going to help resolve a lot of those arguments,” says Christopher Torres, the study’s lead author and a paleontologist at the University of the Pacific. “Chief among them: where is Vegavis perched in the bird tree of life?”
Waterfowl or Something Else? The Debate Heats Up
Even with this new fossil evidence, paleontologists are divided over what kind of bird Vegavis really was. Early studies suggested that it was a distant ancestor of ducks and geese, but the new skull suggests a very different lifestyle.
“So this bird was a foot-propelled pursuit diver,” Torres explains. “It used its legs to propel itself underwater as it swam, and something that we were able to observe directly from this new skull was it had jaw musculature [that] was associated with snapping its mouth shut underwater in pursuit of fish.”
That description sounds more like loons and grebes—modern diving birds—than ducks or geese. And some scientists are not convinced that Vegavis belonged to the group that eventually gave rise to modern waterfowl.
“This fossil is exciting,” says Chase Brownstein, an evolutionary biologist at Yale University, “but I’m not yet convinced it means Vegavis was a duck ancestor.”
Antarctica: A Hidden Sanctuary for Early Birds?
One of the biggest implications of the Vegavis discovery is what it suggests about Antarctica during the late Cretaceous Period. Today, it’s a frozen wasteland, but 69 million years ago, it was a lush, temperate region teeming with vegetation.
Some researchers now speculate that Antarctica may have provided a refuge for early birds, allowing them to survive the cataclysmic asteroid impact that wiped out their dinosaur relatives.
“Antarctica is in many ways the final frontier for our understanding of life during the Age of Dinosaurs,” says Matthew Lamanna, a paleontologist at the Carnegie Museum of Natural History.
With more fossils still waiting to be discovered beneath the ice, the story of how birds survived while the dinosaurs perished is far from over.
This article has been republished from the following materials. Note: material may have been edited for length and content. For further information, please contact the cited source.
