How Did Gargantuan Galaxies Appear So Soon After the Big Bang?




How  monster galaxies appeared shortly (in cosmological time) after the Big Bang is one of the most debated questions of modern astrophysics. An elliptical galaxy 12 billion light years away defies conventional models of its origins: it must have accumulated its enormous mass within 1.8 billion years after the big bang, less than 13% of the present age of the universe. Most elliptical galaxies, such as C1-23152 at the center of a galaxy cluster, take many billions of years to reach their massive sizes. Hence the enduring mystery of how and why this monster object came to exist in the early universe.

The Enigma of C1-23152

An anatomy of the enigma was performed by  a team of astronomers using the Large Binocular Telescope Observatory (LBT) atop Mount Graham in southeastern Arizona, who collected 17 hours’ worth of light from the abnormally massive object (image above).

Ancient Behemoth Galaxies -Fed by Cosmic Filaments of Dark-Matter Haloes

The most massive galaxies that we observe in the universe reach masses of several hundred billion times that of our Sun. Although they comprise only one third of all galaxies, they contain more than 70% of the stars in the Universe. The current model of galaxy formation – the so-called hierarchical model – predicts that smaller galaxies formed earlier, while more massive systems formed later, through subsequent mergers of the pre-existing smaller galaxies. Hence the enigma of C1-23152 — how these galaxies formed so rapidly is among the most debated questions of modern astrophysics.

ESO’s VISTA survey telescope, which works at near-infrared wavelengths, captured previously hidden massive galaxies that existed when the Universe was in its infancy. By discovering and studying more of these galaxies than ever before, astronomers have for the first time found out exactly when such monster galaxies first appeared.



A Lifespan of Less than 500-Million Years 

“The data show that the formation time of C1-23152, that is the time elapsed between the formation of the first stars from the pre-existing gas to the moment when the star formation has almost completely ceased, is less than 500 million of years” says Paolo Saracco, researcher at INAF in Milan and first author of the article published in The Astrophysical Journal. “Also, from the data collected with LBT we were able to establish that in this short time, corresponding to less than 4 hundredths of the age of the Universe, the galaxy formed a mass equal to about 200 billion stars like the Sun, that is about 450 suns per year.” or more than one per day, a star formation rate almost 300 times higher than the current rate in our galaxy, the Milky Way.”

Gargantuan Galaxies  — Ancestors of the Huge Elliptical Objects That Exist Today

Today’s Milky Way Forms No More than Two New Stars a Year

“The Milky Way now forms no more than two stars a year”, adds Danilo Marchesini, full professor at Tufts University and second author of the article. The large amount of information collected allowed the team to quantify for the first time in a galaxy so distant the abundance of chemical elements heavier than helium (the so-called metallicity). The stars of this ancient galaxy have a higher metallicity than that of our much younger Sun, similar to that observed in the most massive galaxies in the universe today.

Massive Galaxies in the Universe Can Form Extremely Quickly

“These observations showed that the formation of the most massive galaxies in the universe can occur extremely quickly, through an extremely intense star formation process in the early Universe, as for C1-23152″, underscores Francesco La Barbera, researcher at INAF in Naples, in the team that conducted the study.

“Understanding whether the scenario that describes the formation of C1-23152 is a particular case or whether, on the contrary, it is what happens for most of the most massive galaxies in the universe is of fundamental importance since this would require a profound revision of the galaxy formation models”, adds Adriana Gargiulo, also a researcher at INAF in Milan and co-author of the study.

Currently, astronomers can detect only the most massive and brightest galaxies in the early Universe. The recently launched James Webb Space Telescope will soon answer the key question of whether massive elliptical galaxies like C1-23152 are common or rare at high redshift. 

The image at the top of the page shows galaxy C1-23152 at a redshift when the Universe was 1.8 billion years old. The image is the sum of images at different wavelengths taken with the Hubble Space Telescope. Its light profile matches exactly those of typical elliptical galaxies in the local Universe but with a mass of about 200 billions sun-like stars that formed in less than 500 million years.

The image below from the LBT Observatory illustrates the formation scenario of massive elliptical galaxies like C1-23152. Massive primordial gas clouds, falling in the same region under the effect of gravitational force, collide triggering violent and massive star formation processes. The starburst phase is expected to last a few hundred million years during which hundreds to thousands of stars per year are formed, as for C1-23152. The resulting massive elliptical galaxy will then evolve with time, possibly experiencing different evolutionary phenomena depending on its surrounding environment. 

The formation of stellar masses as high as for C1-23152 requires both high masses of gas to convert into stars and particular physical conditions, reports the LBT. A possible scenario hypothesized by the researchers is that massive primordial gas clouds, falling under the effect of gravitational force in the same region, collide, triggering violent and massive star formation processes. From the observational point of view, the precursors of the most massive galaxies could therefore be remote galaxies with a very high rate of star formation.

This image shows an example of starburst galaxies forming about a thousand stars per year at the time of observation. This phase is most likely the formation phase of massive galaxies in the early Universe, like C1-23152.

Why Were the Earliest Galaxies In the Universe Brighter Than Those We See Today?

Galaxy Dark-Matter Halos 40 Million Years After Big Bang

Scientists have found clues elsewhere that may account for these ancient mega galaxies, reports Robin George Andrews for Scientific American: “Anastasia Fialkov, a cosmologist at the University of Cambridge, who was not involved with the latest work, says that, unlike full-blown simulations, analytic physics calculations can “take into account the whole volume of the universe. And they suggest that a small number of dark matter halos capable of initiating star formation show up just 40 million years after the big bang.”

“Buried Monsters of the Early Universe” –Unveiled By the Deepest X-Ray Image Ever Taken


The Last Word

“In the last couple of years, observations have shown the presence of galaxies as massive as C1-23152 at epochs comparable to the one of this galaxy or even earlier,” astronomer Paolo Saracco wrote in an email to The Daily Galaxy in reply to our asking him if C1-23152 was an anomaly or the rule for most massive galaxies. “This definitely shows that massive galaxies were not so rare in the early Universe.” he explained. “I think that the true important thing related to these massive galaxies is not to show whether the current model of galaxy formation is right or wrong. Rather, we should try to catch what we can learn from the existence of such high mass galaxies at such early times.”

“I believe that it would be important to decode the information that these massive galaxies bring with them about the complex physical processes that have taken place to form such huge stellar masses in such a short time,” he explained. “This would be a truth step forward in the comprehension of the physical processes that could take place. The James Webb Space Telescope and and the generation of Extremely Large Telescopes will allow us to gather spatially resolved information about the physical status of their gas and stars “within” these galaxies. I think that these unprecedented observations will be able to shed light on these early phases.”


Source: “The Rapid Build-up of Massive Early-type Galaxies. Supersolar Metallicity, High Velocity Dispersion and Young Age for an ETG at z=3.35”.

Maxwell Moe, astrophysicist, NASA Einstein Fellow, University of Arizona via LBT, INAF, and Scientific American

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.